What to Order at Gideon’s Bakehouse During the Holidays
If you are planning a stop at Disney Springs and love rich, over-the-top desserts, Gideon’s Bakehouse is a must-visit. Known for its nearly half-pound cookies and decadent cake slices, Gideon’s rotates seasonal offerings throughout the year alongside its beloved classics. During the holiday season, two standout seasonal cookies and a rotating lineup of cake slices join the menu, making this an especially popular time to visit.
Here is what you need to know about Gideon’s Bakehouse seasonal treats, what makes them unique, and how to decide which ones are really worth the wait.
What Makes Gideon’s Bakehouse Special
Gideon’s Bakehouse began with a single chocolate chip cookie recipe and grew into one of the most sought-after dessert spots at Disney Springs. Each cookie is intentionally oversized, richly flavored, and packed with mix-ins. The cakes are equally indulgent, featuring bold flavor combinations and thick layers of frosting.
Gideon’s is known for rotating flavors monthly and seasonally, which means no two visits are ever quite the same. Seasonal offerings are available for a limited time and often feature ingredients and flavor profiles tied to the time of year.
Seasonal Cookies at Gideon’s Bakehouse
During the holiday season, two limited-time cookies typically join the menu. These cookies highlight contrasting flavor profiles, making it easy to find something that suits your taste preferences.
Kris Kringle Cookie
The Kris Kringle cookie is a white chocolate coffee bean cookie with a surprisingly complex flavor profile. Made with ground coffee beans from Orlando favorite Lineage Roasters, this cookie balances sweetness with a mild bitterness from the coffee. Notes of coconut, caramel, and vanilla bean add warmth and depth.
If you enjoy coffee-flavored desserts or like vanilla-forward treats with a twist, this cookie is a standout. The white chocolate adds richness without overpowering the coffee, making it a well-balanced option for those who prefer something sweet but not overly sugary. Think coffee and cream, friends. Yummm.
Cookie Vom Krampus
For chocolate lovers, the Cookie Vom Krampus is a clear favorite. This deeply rich chocolate cookie is packed with chocolate throughout and topped with Andes mint candies. The mint flavor is present but controlled, complementing the chocolate rather than overwhelming it.
This cookie is ideal if you enjoy dark chocolate desserts or mint-and-chocolate combinations, which I do. The texture is dense and moist, and the multiple layers of chocolate make it feel especially indulgent. This is an incredible cookie.
Seasonal Cake Slices at Gideon’s Bakehouse
In addition to cookies, Gideon’s offers rotating cake slices that change daily. During the holiday season, you may see themed cake slices inspired by the same flavors as the seasonal cookies.
Krampus Cake Slice
One standout seasonal cake is the Krampus cake. This red velvet cake is layered with ultra-minty chocolate cream cheese frosting and includes crushed cookie and candy elements for added texture. The mint flavor is bold and refreshing, making this cake feel especially festive.
Because of its frosting, this cake is best enjoyed while kept cool. If you plan to spend several hours at Disney Springs, consider timing your visit so you can enjoy the cake shortly after purchasing it.
Tips for Visiting Gideon’s Bakehouse
- Follow Gideon’s Bakehouse on social media to see daily cake slice offerings and seasonal announcements.
- Expect a line or the need to join a virtual queue, especially during evenings and peak seasons. Lines tend to move steadily, but patience is key.
- If you are purchasing multiple cookies, ask the cast member how to store them. Some cookies are packaged separately to prevent flavors from transferring.
- Cake slices should be kept cool whenever possible, especially those with mint or cream cheese frosting.
- Don’t forget to ask for napkins and utensils at checkout if you plan to eat immediately. This is essential in my book.
Is Gideon’s Bakehouse Worth the Visit?
Gideon’s Bakehouse is worth the stop if you enjoy bold, indulgent desserts and don’t mind sharing or saving treats for later. Seasonal offerings add an extra layer of excitement, especially for repeat visitors who enjoy trying something new.
Whether you prefer coffee-forward cookies, rich chocolate desserts, or festive cake slices, Gideon’s seasonal menu offers something memorable. For many guests, it becomes a highlight of their Disney Springs experience. Which Gideon’s Bakehouse treat is your favorite?
Join me virtually as I eat my way through Gideon’s holiday treats via the video below:
Rent DVC points, and save up to 65% compared to booking directly through Disney! Browse the confirmed reservations or request a free quote.
